The History of Squire’s Castle: Is it Haunted?

The history of Squire’s Castle starts with the name. Squires Castle is a bit of a misnomer- it’s really a shell of a building in the North Chagrin Reservation in the Cleveland Metroparks with a giant expanse of grass perfect for picnicking.

History of Squire’s Castle

Fergus Squire was an executive with Standard Oil Company. He lived on Euclid Avenue in Cleveland and eventually moved to Cobblestone Garth, a Victorian mansion on Wickliffe’s Millionaire Row. Squire married Louisa Christiana Braymaier on the day after Christmas in 1976.

In 1890, he purchased 525 acres of forested land east of Cleveland and called it River Farm Estate. He planned to turn it into an English country estate with a manor house. In 1895, he started constructing a gatekeeper’s house in the Romanesque Revival style and finished in 1897. German and English castles inspired it.

The Castle’s Structure

The rustic structure lacked electricity, gas, and running water. Squires Castle was built with Euclid bluestone (blue sandstone) quarried nearby. It had a ground floor, two upper floors, and a basement. Unfortunately, today you can only explore the ground floor of this gatehouse.

Plaques with a map of the castle, "the castle today", "The castle as it was" and a Squire's Castle plaque.

The plaques adorning the walls describe the rich history of Squire’s Castle:

The ‘castle’ as it was: The castle had several bedrooms, living areas, a large kitchen, and a breakfast porch. All the castle rooms had white plaster walls and elegant woodwork. Leaded glass windows looked out on the property. The room you are standing in was one of the most beautiful rooms in the home. It was Squire’s library or hunting room. This cozy room was filled with books, trophy cabinets, stuffed animal specimens, and paintings.”

The Castle Today: Squire’s Castle is a favorite place for families to visit. Picnicking, hiking, and enjoying wildflowers are all part of the castle experience. But mostly the castle is a place to let your imagination wander, where you can explore, daydream, and reflect on a time gone by.”

Squire's Castle in the distance on a gray day

Mr. Squire ran into trouble after having trouble obtaining building materials and labor. He and his daughter used the space as a weekend country home. They spent the majority of the summer of 1903 there. However, Squire’s wife disliked the gatehouse and it was essentially abandoned after 1908.

After he retired from Standard Oil in 1909, Squire seldom visited the castle. He and his family toured Europe. He also became a single term mayor of Wickliffe and sold the estate in 1922 to developers who went bankrupt.

The history of Sqiure's Castle described above fireplace

The Haunting

The Willoughby Hills, Ohio structure is allegedly haunted. The legend explains that Squire’s wife woke one night during a storm and went downstairs to investigate. She was startled by the dead stuffed heads of animals in the structure’s trophy room that was illuminated by crashing lightning. She fell down the stairs and broke her neck.

The brick walls of Squire's Castle showing where upper floors once were.

According to legend, the ghost continues to float through Squire’s Castle. However, the legends surrounding the haunting of the property are false. She did not die at the estate, but she died on October 29, 1927, at Cobblestone Garth.

A view of Squire's Castle exterior toward's the library or hunting room

How it Entered the Cleveland Metroparks

A local bank eventually seized the estate, and the Cleveland Park Board purchased the land from the bank in 1925. Most importantly, they named it Squire’s Castle and removed the upper floors, and filled in the basement.

Squires Castle was destroyed over the years. In other words, vandals smashed the leaded glass windows and removed all architectural details. In 1995, the structure was somewhat restored. Today, children love the space and had a blast with the vast amount of space.

Four children gathered at the breakfast porch

Live-action role-play occurs in the expanse of grass out front. Weddings happen- engagements occur. Magic happens at Squire’s Castle, and this is a must-do day trip!

Squire's castle with a group of adults with shields and swords out front on the grass

Do you love a historical backstory? Please let me know in the comments!

We are always adventuring. After that, most tales make it to our blog. However, we update social media more frequently. While our adventures have turned to more local day trips, they are still as exciting as ever before!

Follow us on FacebookInstagram, and Twitter.

Sign up for our email list for a monthly update about what we’re up to!

Leave a Reply